Welcome to Brooklyn's Finest Pizza
Brooklyn's Finest Pizza, located in Staten Island, NY, offers a variety of delicious pizzas and American wraps. With options for delivery, takeout, catering, and vegetarian choices, this casual spot is perfect for groups, families, and solo diners. Customers rave about the quality and taste of their food, with favorites like the margherita pizza, Sicilian slices, and fried Oreos. Past customers have noted the friendly service and quick turnaround on orders. If you're looking for a satisfying pizza experience, Brooklyn's Finest Pizza is a must-try.
- 1250 Hylan Blvd Staten Island, NY 103051250 Hylan Blvd Staten Island, NY 10305 Hotline: (718) 815-7070
Welcome to Brooklyn's Finest Pizza, a beloved gem located at 1250 Hylan Blvd in Staten Island, NY. Renowned for its handcrafted pizzas and authentic Italian flavors, this eatery offers an extensive menu that caters to all cravings, from classic pies to hearty heroes.
At Brooklyn's Finest, the heart of their culinary magic lies in the use of fresh ingredients. Dive into their margherita pizza, a crowd favorite praised for its perfect balance of fresh mozzarella, flavorful basil, and tangy tomato sauce. Customer Anna R. shares her enthusiasm, stating, "We always come every month for their pizzas." This testament underlines the restaurant's ability to deliver consistently delicious meals that keep patrons returning for more.
The menu does not stop with pizzas; it expands into a variety of scrumptious chicken and roast beef heroes. Satisfy your hunger with the 'Chicken with Fresh Mozzarella and Broccoli Rabe Hero' for just $8.99, or the mouthwatering 'Hot Double-Dipped Roast Beef Hero' for $8.49. With options that range from delectable rice balls to unique sandwich specials, there’s something for everyone to indulge in. Eric C. aptly describes the convenience of their offerings, highlighting, "Sometimes you just want a slice of pizza and a chicken parm hero at an awkward time—and they will be there with polite customer service."
What truly sets Brooklyn's Finest Pizza apart is its commitment to inviting service and customer satisfaction. Loyal patrons like Samantha F. and James T. laud the friendly atmosphere and the delightful surprise of new menu items, such as the recently introduced Sicilian pizza. Reflecting on a remarkable turnaround, Ellie N. notes, "I feel as though their pizza has improved tremendously." Such dynamic feedback illustrates the evolving quality and creativity that Brooklyn's Finest delivers.
To top off your experience, don’t miss their fried Oreos, a delightful treat that encapsulates the playful side of this eatery. Whether it’s a casual evening or a late-night craving, Brooklyn's Finest Pizza stands ready to satisfy your appetite with warmth and hospitality. So, the next time you're in Staten Island and in the mood for exceptional pizza, remember this vibrant slice of Brooklyn history. Taste the love, tradition, and flavors that define Brooklyn's Finest Pizza—your taste buds will thank you!

I love them. They come in so handy in those times of need. Sometimes you just want a slice of pizza and a chicken parm hero at an awkward time - and they will be there with polite customer service. Their food is all yummy so you'll be satisfied.

Love their margarita pizza! We always come every month for their pizzas. The service is good, workers are friendly and nice. Order is always made on time and fresh.

They just started doing Sicilian its very very good, reminds me of DaVinci in Brooklyn a really good square slice, try it you'll like it

Pizza super good can't go wrong with the fried Oreos definitely a quick spot for food I love going here

I remember over 5 years ago when I tried brooklyns finest pizza it was mediocore, but I have tried it again recently the past couple months and I'm not sure what they changed, but I feel as though their pizza has improved tremendously. Have been ordering regularly since when I have a pizza craving